This commentary is by Greg Guma, a writer who lives in Burlington.
After viewing the avalanche of lies called a CNN Town Hall with Donald Trump, this is what initially came to mind: Another season of chaos has begun, a no-rules battle to define reality waged by successful psychopaths.
But at least we know more about what to expect.
How it will end? No spoilers, but the Russia-Ukraine war isn’t likely to be settled until after the 2024 elections, Americans will continue to sort themselves both geographically and culturally, and no legal process will prevent Trump from running.
Don’t expect debates; they’re becoming archaic. Politics has become part of a global information war for control of “the narrative” and the world.
Successful psychopaths? Aren’t you exaggerating? Not really. Millions of people are fascinated, often even seduced, by people whose behavior actually points to pathology. The Trump cult apparently has millions of members; many are ready to take up arms and deny reality for their leader.
Maybe we are wired to be attracted by narcissists, sociopaths and psychopaths, people so focused on their own central role in whatever takes place that the rest of us are sucked into their reality.
Is Trump a psychopath? He does score well on a 20-item checklist. Are there more around us than we think? Not just serial killers and the violent type, but successful, powerful psychopaths who will do anything to win and affect our lives in profound ways?
The checklist, a way to help identify potential psychopaths among us, was developed by Bob Hare, a prison psychologist who conducted remarkable experiments and eventually codified his findings. Jon Ronson provides an excellent history and analysis in his book ”The Psychopath Test.”
Here’s the basic list, a collection of tendencies and an analytical tool to spot those who might be functioning psychopaths. Keep in mind that having mild tendencies doesn’t make you a psychopath. But a high score — more than 30 on Hare’s 40-point scale — should be a warning sign.
1. Glibness, superficial charm
2. Grandiose sense of self-worth
3. Need for stimulation, proneness to boredom
4. Pathological lying
5. Conning, manipulative
6. Lack of remorse or guilt
7. Shallow affect
8. Callous, lack of empathy
9. Parasitic lifestyle
10. Poor behavioral control
11. Promiscuous sexual behavior
12. Early behavior problems
13. Lack of realistic long-term goals
14. Impulsivity
15. Irresponsibility
16. Failure to accept responsibility for own actions
17. Many short-term marital relationships
18. Juvenile delinquency
19. Revocation of conditional release
20. Criminal versatility
In his book, Ronson follows the trail of research about psychopaths, gets to know a few, and sees how they have affected society. For example, he tracks down Toto Constant, former leader of Haitian death squads backed by the CIA, who was given asylum in the U.S. but restricted to Queens.
Although the guy was basically in hiding, he still thought he was beloved in Haiti (#2), took no responsibility for his crimes (#16), and badly imitated strong emotions. Since psychopaths don’t experience emotions the same as other people (#7), they often compensate through imitation. But not all are excellent actors. Constant even thought he would someday be called back to “help” Haiti again (#13).
Psychopaths could be the reason the world seems so screwed up. If so, humanity’s tragic flaw may be that a few bad apples — people whose amygdalas don’t fire the right signals to their central nervous systems — really can spoil the whole barrel.
Prime examples include the corporate psychopaths who trashed capitalism in 2008. To dig into that group check out “Snakes in Suits: When Psychopaths Go to Work” by Hare and Paul Babiak. Examining these financial terrorists, you might well conclude that the conspiracy theory about shape-shifting lizards who secretly rule the world isn’t so far off. After all, psychopaths are often social shape-shifters.
The question is: Do psychopaths run the country and maybe the world? It only takes a few to destabilize a financial system, poison a community or destroy a business. Some studies suggest that, percentage-wise, there are more potential psychopaths among CEOs, directors and supervisors than in the general population, or even in prisons.
Who hasn’t known a business type who was borderline, a mercurial tyrant subject to fits of rage and impulsive acts? Or followed a public figure who was charming but also irresponsible, manipulative and self-aggrandizing?
The telltale signs of the psychopath are often ignored or excused. In his book, Ronson recalls a meeting with businessman Al Dunlop, a ruthless executive famous for his apparent joy in firing people. Together they go through Hare’s psychopath checklist and Dunlop simply redefines many of the traits as aspects of leadership.
Impulsiveness becomes quick analysis. Grandiose sense of self-worth? Absolutely, you have to believe in yourself, says Dunlop. Manipulative? Hey, that’s just leadership. Inability to feel deep emotions? Emotions are mostly nonsense, he says. And not feeling remorse frees you up to do great things.
Donald Trump would likely give similar responses if confronted with his own psychopathic tendencies. And they apparently don’t disqualify him from being president.
